Unfortunately, I hadn't made tator tot casserole in years. And by years, I mean not since my college days with my old roomie Stefanie. Stefanie made a mean tator tot casserole (and her and her husband just had their first baby two days ago, so congratulations!!!). I remembered the basics of tator tot casserole. It is pretty simple, after all. But I wasn't feeling overly confident in my ability to recreate Stefanie's yummy version which I had loved so much.
So I went to my old-school cookbooks thinking that somewhere in those pages of good old comfort food and casserole recipes I was bound to find at least one tried-and-true tator tot casserole recipe. I was wrong. In all my cookbooks, I didn't have one tator tot casserole recipe. I guess all those church ladies and farmer's wives assumed that anyone with a brain in their skull and an oven in their kitchen just knew how to make tator tot casserole. The good news is that thanks to a little invention called the internet, I knew I could scrounge up a tasty recipe in no time. So I got to searching.